I like it. I think your new format is much clearer and easier than the old one. Having all the possible ship combinations in place made each post long, and didn't really add that much. The new format gives a better strategical overlook.
I also like the way you present different options for using the main weapon.
As for criticism of content, I'm not a netplayer so I wouldn't know. Perhaps adding something about how quickly the Guardian depletes it's battery in comet form? If you don't pay attention, you'll risk getting stranded in front of the enemy.